When it comes to pizza, Salina has the perfect bite to satisfy your craving. From foldable New York-style slices, to forkfuls of deep-dish gooey-ness, to take-and-bake classics fresh from your own oven, this guide has you covered.
Here’s your go-to list of all the best pizza places in Salina, Kansas—from local hidden gems to your favorite nationwide chains!
🍕 Local Legends: The Must-Try Pizzerias
1. Coop’s Pizzeria – A Salina Staple
📍 Address: 1219A West Crawford Street
🔥 Best For: Handmade, fresh-dough pizzas with generous toppings. Along with homemade sauces and dressings
⭐ Fan Favorite: Their signature Meatarian Pizza—loaded with all the good stuff.
💭 Why you should go: Coop’s Pizzeria is a local favorite, serving up delicious, homemade pizza in a cozy atmosphere. Perfect for a casual dinner with family or friends!
2. Big Cheese Pizza – Best for Cheesy Goodness
📍 Address: 730 South Broadway Blvd
🔥 Best For: Extra cheesy, gooey pizza made with the freshest ingredients at a great price.
⭐ Fan Favorite: Perfect 10 Pizza – includes a variety of fresh toppings along with various meats.
💭 Why you should go: This place is perfect for those who love thick layers of cheese and a classic, satisfying slice. Plus, they offer great lunch specials!
AD SPACE AVAILABLE
3. Gambino’s Pizza – Best for Classic Midwest Pizza
📍 Address: 2000 South Ninth Street
🔥 Best For: Thick, hearty crusts and a wide variety of toppings. Always reliable in serving good quality pizzas and having a friendly atmosphere.
⭐ Fan Favorite: The Mobster Pizza—a fully loaded supreme pie.
💭 Why you should go: If you love traditional, hearty pizza with a Midwest twist, Gambino’s is a must-try. It’s a family-friendly spot with something for everyone!
4. Blue Sky Brewery and Eats – Best for Craft Pizza & Beer
📍 Address: 116 North Santa Fe Avenue
🔥 Best For: Artisan, wood-fired pizzas paired with local craft beers.
⭐ Fan Favorite: BBQ Chicken Pizza—smoky, tangy, and delicious!
💭 Why you should go: This spot is perfect for those who love gourmet-style pizza with a craft beer experience. Even better — they feature a weekly flavor to keep things exciting!
🍕 Popular Chains: Where to Grab a Classic Slice
5. Domino’s Pizza – Best for Fast & Customizable Pizza
📍Address: 1621 South Ohio Street
🔥 Best For: Quick delivery, online ordering, and customizable options.
⭐ Fan Favorite: Hand-Tossed Pepperoni Pizza—a simple classic done right.
💭 Why you should go: Domino’s is a solid go-to for a fast and affordable pizza night. Plus, their rewards program makes it easy to earn free pizza!
6. Pizza Hut – Best for Stuffed Crust Lovers
📍 Multiple Locations in Salina: 1200 South Sante Fe Avenue & 2935 South Ninth Street
🔥 Best For: Their famous Stuffed Crust Pizza and family meal deals.
⭐ Fan Favorite: Meat Lover’s Pan Pizza—crispy on the outside, soft on the inside.
💭 Why you should go: If you love thick crusts and cheesy goodness, Pizza Hut is a classic choice.
7. Papa John’s – Best for Fresh Ingredients
📍 Address: 1650 South Ohio Street
🔥 Best For: Fresh dough, better ingredients, and their famous garlic dipping sauce.
⭐ Fan Favorite: The Works Pizza—a supreme-style pie loaded with meats and veggies.
💭 Why you should go: Papa John’s is perfect for those who love a fresh, flavorful pizza with lots of toppings. Plus, their garlic sauce is legendary!
8. Little Caesars – Best for Budget-Friendly Pizza
📍Address: 645 East Crawford Street
🔥 Best For: Quick, affordable, and always “Hot-N-Ready.”
⭐ Fan Favorite: Extra Most Bestest Pepperoni Pizza—tons of pepperoni for a low price.
💭 Why you should go: If you need a quick, cheap, and tasty pizza, Little Caesars is always a solid option!
9. Papa Murphy’s – Best for DIY Pizza at Home
📍 Multiple Locations in Salina: 2365 South Ninth Street
🔥 Best For: Fresh, take-and-bake pizzas with customizable toppings.
⭐ Fan Favorite: Chicken Garlic Pizza—a white sauce masterpiece.
💭 Why you should go: If you want the freshest pizza straight from your own oven, Papa Murphy’s is the way to go!
10. Old Chicago – Best for Deep Dish & Beer Pairings
📍 Address: 214 South Santa Fe Avenue
🔥 Best For: Chicago-style deep-dish and a great beer selection.
⭐ Fan Favorite: The Chicago 7 Pizza—a fully loaded deep-dish pie.
💭 Why you should go: If you want a hearty, deep-dish pizza and a cold craft beer, Old Chicago is your place!
🍕 Best Gas Station Pizza in Salina
11. Sbarro – Best for Classic New York Slices
📍 Address (inside a Kwikshop): 1727 West Crawford St
🔥 Best For: Huge, foldable slices of New York-style pizza.
⭐ Fan Favorite: Pepperoni XL Slice—big, cheesy, and satisfying.
💭 Why you should go: If you want that authentic New York-style slice, Sbarro delivers. Perfect for a quick grab-and-go meal!
12. Hunt Brothers Pizza – Best for Gas Station Pizza Done Right
📍 Multiple Locations in Salina: 100 North Broadway Blvd & 2124 North Hedville Road
🔥 Best For: Grab-and-go pizza, along with their ‘All Toppings & No Extra Charge’ policy that’ll make you want to keep coming back.
⭐ Fan Favorite: Loaded Breakfast Pizza—yes, pizza for breakfast!
💭 Why you should go: Sometimes, gas station pizza hits the spot, and Hunt Brothers does it better than most!
13. Casey’s – Best for Gas Station Pizza
Multiple Locations in Salina:
📍 500 North Ohio St
📍 1100 East Iron Ave
📍 215 West Crawford St
📍 2404 South Ninth St
🔥 Best For: Late-night pizza cravings and breakfast pizza.
⭐ Fan Favorite: Sausage Breakfast Pizza—eggs, cheese, and gravy on a pizza? Yes, please!
💭 Why you should go: Casey’s proves that gas station pizza can be shockingly good!
So, Where’s Your Next Pizza Stop? 🍕
Salina is packed with incredible pizza spots, ensuring that no matter what you’re craving—whether it’s a hearty deep-dish, a classic New York-style slice, or a gourmet creation loaded with unique toppings—you’ll find the perfect place to satisfy your pizza cravings.
ADVERTISEMENT
